The Risks of Collecting Biometric Data

Biometric data includes unique physical and genetic markers, such as facial recognition details, iris patterns, fingerprints, voice identifiers, gait patterns, and specific DNA segments. Increasingly, companies are using biometric information to strengthen authentication processes, implement secure access controls, tailor marketing campaigns, and monitor employee attendance. However, while biometric data offers considerable advantages, its collection presents significant privacy, security, and compliance risks. This article explores these risks, the regulatory environment surrounding biometric data, and practical risk management tips for organizations.

Potential Risks in Biometric Data Collection

Collecting and storing biometric data is accompanied by several inherent risks, particularly related to privacy, security, and organizational reputation. Here are some key risks involved:

1. Privacy Concerns

Biometric data is uniquely personal. Unlike usernames, passwords, or PINs, biometric identifiers cannot be altered or reset if compromised. This immutability raises ethical concerns regarding the collection of such sensitive information and the potential for its misuse. When organizations collect and store biometric data, they bear the responsibility of protecting these private details from unauthorized access and exploitation, as any compromise can lead to severe privacy violations.

2. Security Threats

Due to its sensitivity and value, biometric data is an attractive target for cybercriminals. Security breaches involving biometric data can result in severe consequences for both organizations and stakeholders. For example, identity theft stemming from compromised biometric information can lead to long-term issues for individuals, especially since the genetic component of some biometric data can even impact relatives of those affected. Consequently, securing this data is crucial, as inadequate security measures could lead to substantial and lasting repercussions for affected stakeholders.

3. Reputational Risks

In today’s digital landscape, consumers are increasingly critical of organizations’ data protection practices. Failure to protect biometric data or effectively respond to security incidents can severely damage a company’s reputation. Organizations that mishandle biometric data risk losing public trust, customer loyalty, and even employee morale. Maintaining strong security protocols can help protect not only the data itself but also the organization’s reputation and relationships with stakeholders.

Navigating the Evolving Regulatory Landscape

The legal framework governing biometric data collection is complex and continually evolving, with various jurisdictions implementing unique data protection laws. Compliance with these regulations is essential for organizations to avoid legal and financial penalties. Below is an overview of key legislation that impacts the collection and handling of biometric data.

Federal Legislation in the United States

Although there is no federal law specifically targeting biometric data, certain federal statutes regulate personal data collection within specific sectors. These include the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), which provide guidelines for handling sensitive personal information in healthcare and online environments for minors, respectively.

State-Level Legislation

Several U.S. states have enacted laws that specifically address biometric data protection:

Illinois’ Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA): Established in 2008, BIPA prohibits Illinois-based organizations from collecting biometric data without prior notification and written consent. This act also permits individuals to take legal action against organizations violating its provisions.

Texas’ Capture or Use of Biometric Identifiers Act (CUBI): Introduced in 2009, CUBI requires organizations to notify and obtain explicit consent from individuals before collecting their biometric data for commercial purposes. The law also mandates the destruction of biometric data within a “reasonable” timeframe after its intended use.

Washington’s Biometric Privacy Protection Act (HB 1493): Enacted in 2017, this legislation restricts Washington-based organizations from collecting biometric identifiers without notifying and securing consent from individuals. The law also requires protective mechanisms to prevent unauthorized data release or sale.

International Regulation

Outside the U.S., the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union places stringent restrictions on biometric data collection. Under the GDPR, biometric data is classified as a “special category of personal information,” subjecting it to rigorous protection requirements. Organizations must obtain explicit consent from EU residents before collecting their biometric data and perform thorough data protection assessments to safeguard it.

Broader Privacy Laws Addressing Biometric Data

Some states, such as California, Virginia, and Colorado, have introduced broader data privacy laws that include specific provisions for biometric data:

California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA): Effective from 2023, the CPRA categorizes biometric data as “sensitive personal information.” Organizations collecting such data must disclose how it will be used, processed, and whether it will be shared with third parties.

Virginia Consumer Data Protection Act (VCDPA): Enforced in 2023, the VCDPA requires organizations to obtain consent before collecting biometric data from Virginia residents and mandates comprehensive documentation of data collection practices.

Colorado Privacy Act (CPA): Similar to the VCDPA, the CPA enforces data protection standards for organizations operating in Colorado. However, it includes specific consent guidelines that focus on obtaining individual authorization before collecting biometric data.

As more states introduce biometric data privacy laws, organizations will need to stay up-to-date on legislation to remain compliant. Non-compliance could lead to costly penalties, ranging from thousands to millions of dollars, as well as potential litigation initiated by affected stakeholders.

Effective Risk Management for Biometric Data Collection

Given the risks and complex regulations associated with biometric data, organizations should adopt the following risk management strategies to enhance data security and maintain compliance:

1. Conduct Regular Risk Assessments

Organizations should perform routine assessments to identify specific vulnerabilities related to biometric data. By understanding potential threats, they can develop strategies to address risks before they result in data breaches or compliance issues.

2. Implement Strong Data Privacy Practices

Protecting biometric data starts with minimizing its collection, processing, and storage. Techniques such as data minimization ensure that only essential biometric information is retained, reducing exposure. Additionally, “cancelable biometrics”—where data is modified to make it useless to attackers—can enhance data security without compromising operational integrity.

3. Utilize Advanced Technical Controls

Organizations should implement technical safeguards like encryption, access controls, and multi-factor authentication to protect biometric data from unauthorized access. Third-party vendors should also adhere to these security standards to prevent supply chain vulnerabilities.

4. Provide Ongoing Employee Training

All employees should be educated on the organization’s biometric data protocols, especially those directly handling such information. Regular training sessions are essential to keep employees informed of evolving risks and regulatory updates, ensuring they follow best practices.

5. Maintain Legal Compliance

Organizations should work closely with legal counsel to ensure that their data collection practices comply with applicable laws. This includes developing consent protocols, transparently communicating data usage policies, and implementing stringent data storage and disposal practices.

6. Develop Cyber Incident Response Plans

A proactive cyber incident response plan can help mitigate the impact of security breaches involving biometric data. Regular testing and updating of this plan are critical for effective crisis management in the event of a data breach.

7. Secure Appropriate Insurance Coverage

Organizations should consider purchasing insurance policies to cover potential losses arising from biometric data security incidents. Consulting with an insurance expert can help identify suitable coverage options for specific data security risks.

Conclusion

The collection of biometric data offers operational benefits, but it carries significant risks related to privacy, security, and compliance. Organizations that collect biometric data must remain vigilant by staying informed about relevant legislation, enforcing robust security practices, and regularly assessing risk management measures. By prioritizing these strategies, organizations can secure biometric data and foster trust with their stakeholders.

For further guidance on biometric data risk management and insurance solutions, contact us today at 909.466.7876!

Also, discover more about The Role of Digital Forensics and Incident Response in Cybersecurity and the Cybersecurity Challenges in the Construction Industry as well as how to overcome them!